Prep Volleyball: The Quiet Powerhouse of the Fall

While most of the fall’s headlines were dominated by stadium lights and Friday-night dramatics, the gyms across southern New Mexico were producing the truly defining story of the season. Volleyball — often overshadowed by football’s cultural gravity — delivered the most complete, top-to-bottom performance of any sport in the region. The district alignments were clearer, the competitive tiers more defined, and the level of excellence unmistakable. From dynastic domination in Class 5A to deep postseason runs in the small-school divisions, local programs continued to demonstrate that the Neighbors Cup is as much about culture as it is about records.

This year’s distribution of points tells the story plainly:

Neighbors Cup – Volleyball Points

• Las Cruces (5A): 8 points — 3 for winning district, 5 for winning the state championship
• Organ Mountain (5A): 2 points — 2nd place in district
• Centennial (5A): 1 point — 3rd place in district
• Santa Teresa (4A): 2 points — 2nd place in district
• Chaparral (4A): 1 point — 3rd place in district
• Hatch Valley (3A): 1 point — 3rd place in district
• Mesilla Valley Christian (2A): 3 points — 1st place in district

Across every class, volleyball showcased programs that were disciplined, joyful, and steadily building traditions that match or exceed their gridiron counterparts — even if they do so with less fanfare.

Class 5A: The Bulldawgs and the Monsters at the Net

If football supplied the drama this fall, volleyball supplied the inevitability. Las Cruces didn’t simply win — they ruled. A third straight state championship, a second consecutive undefeated season, and not a single set dropped in district play. What the Bulldawgs accomplished in 2025 reads less like a season and more like a continuation of a legacy being written in real time.

Photo Courtesy LCHS Bulldawg Volleyball (via Facebook)

But what makes them singular isn’t merely their record; it’s the constellation of talent on the floor. And while the statewide spotlight naturally gravitates toward the program’s brightest star — Addison Massey, two-time Gatorade New Mexico Volleyball Player of the Year and back-to-back MaxPreps State Player of the Year — the Bulldawgs were powered by multiple “monsters” waiting on the outside. Ava Price, another All-State outside hitter, hammered home point after point with a quiet consistency that would be headline-worthy anywhere else.

Gatorade and AVCA All-American images courtesy LCHS Bulldawgs Volleyball (via Facebook). MaxPreps “Air Addie” by Las Cruces Digest (Not officially licensed, endorsed or sanctioned by MaxPreps)

Across town, the district produced two more elite outsides: Maggie Coats (Organ Mountain) and Tristan McReynolds (Centennial). In most regions, a single outside hitter with All-State credentials would tilt the scales. Las Cruces had four in one district — a testament to the level at which local volleyball is being played.

Addison Massey and Sydney Pipkin at the 2025 LCPS Fall Sports Media Day. Las Cruces Digest Photo

And yet the most indispensable role on any court — the setter — belonged solely to Las Cruces. Sydney Pipkin, the district’s only All-State setter, operated the offense with a poise shaped by culture as much as by skill. When Las Cruces Digest asked Massey and Pipkin at Media Day about the secret behind the team’s visible joy on the court, Pipkin offered perhaps the deepest insight into this program’s ethos:

“I think having the ‘next ball’ mentality… if you mess up, it’s like: Fine. We’ve got the next one.”

Massey followed:

“It’s definitely cheering on your teammates. If you’re supporting one another it’s a lot easier to have fun.”

That next ball mentality the players noted is a phrase used “all the time” in the gym and on the court—and it’s no accident. Head coach Keith Leupold, already a Hall of Fame inductee, has spent decades cultivating a volleyball culture at Las Cruces grounded in joy, trust, and relentless forward momentum. At one match last season, following a beautiful inside score, Leupold briefly stood from his otherwise quiet courtside seat, furrowed his brow, and shouted only one thing:

“Hey, where’s the clapping?!”

For Leupold, enthusiasm is a fundamental — not an accessory. In a district full of excellent teams, Las Cruces was more than talented; they were delightfully and consistently themselves. And that combination — talent plus culture — tends to yield banners.

Organ Mountain and Centennial: Chasing Greatness in the Age of a Dynasty

Organ Mountain finished district play with only two losses — both to the eventual state champions — securing a well-earned second place and two Neighbors Cup points. The Knights were balanced, disciplined, and anchored by the play of All-State outside hitter Maggie Coats, who delivered some of the most dynamic attacking of the season. In almost any other district in the state, Organ Mountain’s resume would have positioned them as the prohibitive favorite.

Centennial’s journey was defined by margins. More specifically: a single set. The Hawks and Mayfield ended district play tied at 5–5, and they split their head-to-head matches. The tiebreaker? In the one match Centennial lost to the Trojans, the Hawks stole a single set — and that set proved to be the difference, earning them third place and the final 5A Neighbors Cup point.

Centennial’s outside hitter Tristan McReynolds, who earned All-State recognition, served as the emotional and offensive centerpiece for a program navigating a season of transition. Their ties to the top were visible, and their gap to the bottom was secure. In a district where four teams legitimately believe they should be postseason contenders, Centennial held their ground.

Outside the Spotlight: Effort, Environment, and the Limits of Algorithms

One of the persistent truths in high school athletics is that competitive environments are not created equal. District alignments—by geography, enrollment, historical inertia, and the occasional stroke of bureaucratic luck—shape outcomes as surely as on-court talent. Volleyball offered a clear illustration this fall, revealing how two programs can perform with equal grit yet emerge with starkly different rewards on paper.

Take Mayfield. The Trojans spent their season in the crucible of Class 5A’s most top-heavy district, where the undefeated, three-peat state champions (Las Cruces) and an 8-2 in-district runner-up (Organ Mountain) consumed most available oxygen. Mayfield fought through that gauntlet, splitting with Centennial, playing fundamentally sound volleyball, and finishing 5–5 in district—yet walked away with zero Neighbors Cup points. Their performance would have earned hardware in most other districts; here, it earned another lesson in perseverance.

Just one classification down, Santa Teresa lived a parallel story with a different ending. The Desert Warriors tied 4A perennial Silver High at the top of District 3-4A, losing the district title on a statistical tiebreaker. On the floor, Santa Teresa and Mayfield were kindred spirits—experienced teams with strong fundamentals, good coaching, and the grit to go toe-to-toe with programs that traditionally overshadow them. But unlike Mayfield, Santa Teresa’s environment allowed them to escape with something tangible: two Neighbors Cup points for a strong district finish.

The comparison is instructive, if imperfect. It reminds us that the Neighbors Cup reflects results, not always reality, and that sometimes the truest stories of character, progress, and resolve occur at the net where standings fail to capture the whole truth.

Further illustrating this tension, Chaparral (4A) and Hatch Valley (3A) each collected one Neighbors Cup point for finishing third in their respective districts—despite capturing only a single district win apiece. This doesn’t diminish their effort; if anything, it calls attention to how difficult their seasons truly were. Both teams showed competitive flashes, both refused to fold, and both earned the right to count their seasons as steps forward. But their points tally also underscores the asynchronous nature of high-school volleyball ecosystems: some districts are minefields; others are open plains.

Collectively, these cases invite a broader reflection. Success in high-school sports is not solely measured in points, banners, or brackets. It is also measured in resilience, improvement, and the dignity teams show when the environment asks more of them than it gives back. Mayfield’s unrewarded grind, Santa Teresa’s near miss at the top, Chaparral’s endurance, and Hatch Valley’s refusal to disappear are all examples of what competitive integrity actually looks like in our broader community.

This is a reminder that it’s not only the environment that can misrepresent achievement; sometimes, the very ranking algorithms we rely on to measure success miss the mark. The lesson is clear: sportsmanship, effort, and the pursuit of excellence matter far beyond what any scoreboard or point tally might suggest. And as the Neighbors Cup continues to track achievements across every school in our broader community, these moments—quiet, complicated, and easy to miss—are the ones that give the standings their soul.

Rising to Every Challenge: Celebrating Prep Volleyball Across the Classes

Mesilla Valley Christian’s SonBlazers once again demonstrated the rewards and challenges of small-school athletics. The SonBlazers captured their district championship and advanced to the state semifinals, falling just one game short of a title for the second consecutive year. In a small-school environment, the nuances of competition are magnified: every match is against a team with the potential to upset the order, and consistent victories are never guaranteed. Unlike larger programs, where depth can sometimes cushion a loss, success here demands focus, adaptability, and relentless effort—qualities that the SonBlazers displayed in abundance throughout the season.

Across the fall season, prep volleyball showcased the depth, talent, and resilience of our broader community. From the dominant Bulldawgs sweeping through Class 5A undefeated, to the standout performers at Organ Mountain, Centennial, and even often overlooked Mesilla Valley Christian thriving in a small-school environment, the season illustrated that success comes in many forms. Championships and points matter, but so do perseverance, teamwork, and the ability to rise to every challenge presented by a competitive landscape. Whether celebrated on the scoreboard or earned quietly in gyms away from the spotlight, the efforts of these student-athletes define the spirit of prep sports in our region, leaving a lasting impression for seasons to come.

Next Up: Soccer