Loading employment listings… (v3)
Loading sports…
Loading business directory…
Las Cruces Digest
LOADING WEATHER☀—National Weather Service

Loading stories…


NM DOJ

The NRC Grants the New Mexico Department of Justice’s Intervention in Controversial Uranium Mining Project

In its 61-page decision, the panel agreed with the NMDOJ that most of the issues raised in NMDOJ’s petition warranted a hearing.

Source: N.M. Department of Justice

Santa Fe, NM — A panel of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board on Thursday granted the New Mexico Department of Justice’s (NMDOJ) petition to intervene in the licensing renewal for the Crownpoint Uranium Project before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). This important early result means that the NRC will hold a public hearing on the license application of NuFuels, Inc., a subsidiary of Laramide Resources, to determine whether the project can safely restart uranium mining and processing at two locations in McKinley County, Crownpoint and Church Rock.

Receive the latest stories in your inbox every day — FREE!

Subscribe

* indicates required
What would you like us to call you?

“This is a significant and unprecedented step forward in holding uranium mining companies accountable for the risks their projects pose to New Mexico communities,” said Attorney General Raúl Torrez. “What makes this decision particularly important is that the NRC has granted our petition and, for the first time, an NRC panel will directly confront serious questions about whether the uranium industry can actually restore groundwater after this specific type of mining. The applicant’s own disclosures raise serious questions about its ability to protect New Mexico’s water, and the panel recognized that those questions deserve answers in a public hearing. We are making clear that companies seeking to profit from New Mexico’s natural resources must meet the highest standards of transparency, accountability and environmental protection.”
NuFuels holds the only NRC license for uranium mining in New Mexico and under the renewed license intends to produce three million pounds of triuranium octoxide (commonly known as “yellowcake”) each year for up to 20 years. Unlike historic mining in the area, NuFuels plans to use “in situ recovery” (ISR) methods at the Crownpoint Uranium Project, which is located on four sites spanning Bureau of Land Management, Navajo Nation, and private lands.



In its 61-page decision, the panel agreed with the NMDOJ that most of the issues raised in NMDOJ’s petition warranted a hearing. Significantly, the panel noted that, since the last 2009 NRC study on the remediation of groundwater after ISR uranium mining, industry experience has shown that restoration of groundwater to baseline standards after ISR operations may not be feasible: “The State alleges that the last seventeen years have demonstrated industry-wide technological failures in restoring groundwater quality around ISR facilities” and that this “casts doubt” on NuFuels’ reliance on the NRC 2009 report. The panel also noted NuFuels’ own 2023 statements in a project narrative that, to date, “no ISR site has restored all constituents of concern to pre-operational concentrations.” On this issue, the panel concluded that the State raised a genuine and material dispute “that the ER’s failure to address this post-2009 industry experience may negate the [environmental report’s] projected confidence in restoring groundwater quality.”

The panel also agreed that the NMDOJ had raised hearing-worthy arguments that NuFuels’ application was deficient in numerous other respects:

  • - NuFuels failed to analyze the environmental impacts that will result if its planned restoration of the nearby aquifer achieves only fallback groundwater quality standards;
  • - NuFuels failed to examine current groundwater conditions and instead relied on 2011 data;
  • - NuFuels failed to analyze the impacts of mining operations on the Crownpoint community water supply, and failed to disclose the consequences for that supply if restoration of the production zones achieves only fallback groundwater quality standards;
  • - NuFuels did not analyze the impacts of the ongoing arid climate—despite proposing substantial consumptive groundwater use in this arid region over a 20-year license term;
  • - NuFuels failed to discuss important enactments by the Navajo Nation that bear on the proposed project’s land use, transport plan, and schedule: the Diné Natural Resources Protection Act of 2005, which bans new uranium mining until previous mining contamination has been remediated; the Navajo Nation’s Radioactive and Related Substances, Equipment, Vehicles, Persons and Materials Transportation Act of 2012, which restricts the transport of uranium and radioactive substances across Navajo lands; and Navajo Nation Executive Order 04-2023, which reaffirms the Navajo Nation’s commitment to protecting its people and lands from new uranium mining and processing;
  • - NuFuels’ historic and cultural resources analysis rests on outdated archaeological surveys and a decades-old Traditional Cultural Places inventory;
  • - NuFuels failed to disclose that its remediation of preexisting radioactive contamination at the Church Rock Section 17 project area is a binding contractual precondition to commencing ISR operations at Church Rock Section 8 and must be performed under the Navajo Nation Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act;
  • - NuFuels materially misstated site access to the Church Rock Sections 8 and 17 project areas by asserting that primary access “is from NM 566,” when the applicant’s predecessor acknowledged in a 2012 Agreement with the Navajo Nation that the NM 566 right-of-way does not intersect Section 8 and covenanted not to cross Navajo Nation trust lands to access Section 8 except pursuant to a right-of-way consented to by the Nation;
  • - NuFuels failed to demonstrate compliance with federal uranium mining regulations because it contains no current decommissioning and aquifer restoration cost estimate, stating only that the NRC approved revised restoration plans in 2011 and that annual surety updates will be submitted.

The panel’s full opinion is attached.